Nov 062016
 

Womanizer vs Satisfyer - a line up of the 3 Womanizer models and the Satisfyer Pro 2

For quite some time I regarded the Womanizer with a healthy dose of side-eye; I was quite sure that it wouldn’t work for me. I remained skeptical of the many glowing reviews. When you’ve been reviewing sex toys for 8 years, you can often get a really good feel for the facts just by reading a handful of reviews. But the Womanizer shocked me – in fact, it left me speechless. It took me months to write my first Womanizer review because I felt like I couldn’t explain why I liked it or who else might like it (or hate it). I also was having a really hard time admitting I liked something THAT ugly with THAT bad of a name and that high of a price tag1. The Womanizer W100 makes the original copper Eroscillator look damn good.

A screencap of an email I received recently from one of the many misguided Chinese plants who think I'm a manufacturer or retailer, not a blogger. They offer me low wholesale prices and the ability to put my name on their stuff. The photo shows knockoffs of the Lovehoney tongueslapper and Womanizer-like toys. Like anything popular, counterfeit / copycat products quickly flooded Amazon, AliExpress, eBay, etc.  It never takes long after “white label”2 versions of popular brands are available for the emails about them to start hitting my inbox3.  As you can see in this email screenshot there’s a knock-off of the Womanizer tech in a different body with a wholesale price of $20.

When I saw the Satisfyer brand, it was really clear that they’re going after the Womanizer market with this non-vibrating air-pulsation technology – they went the cheap route though with the motor and design, allowing the retail price to be so much lower than the Womanizer that they were guaranteed to steal a large chunk of the Womanizer’s potential customers. The company behind the Satisfyer has denied that they’ve outright copied the Womanizer tech; Womanizer responded by slapping them with patent infringement but it won’t hold water outside of Germany.  At first glance, Satisfyer seemed to have fixed the primary complaints about Womanizer: design, name, price and waterproof abilities.  But when you use the Satisfyer Pro 2 side-by-side with any Womanizer it’s glaringly obvious that the price increase with the Womanizer will get you a product that seems to be better made. I also just have a really hard time supporting a product that is such an obvious rip-off – maybe you don’t agree, and you need to have the most affordable option which I respect. **After this post went live** two folks commented via Facebook about their interactions with Satifyer reps at SHE NYC. One said: “True story, at this years SHE Expo in Brooklyn the Satisfyer representative said flat out to my wife and I that they took the “poorly designed Womanizer and made it better” then proceeded to essentially brag about how they got away with it adding how they considered a powerful patent lawyer part of the cost of bringing the Satisfyer to market. I mean, the guy was chuckling about it.” You know, this is not how a decent company behaves. At all. Jesus fuck.

Womanizer PRO40

Womanizer PRO40Until recently, Womanizer remained an overpriced, luxury item. When you get it in your hands it doesn’t feel quite as well-made as some brands. It lacks the pretty, “classic”, refined beauty that has drawn people to Lelo, L’amourose, etc. And while $99 for the new Womanizer PRO40 still is considered luxury, out-of-reach pricing to many, it’s a bit more attainable than $159.  The Womanizer PRO40 is clearly epi24’s answer to the sales lost to the $59 Satisfyer Pro 2 – and unlike the W100 or W500, the more affordable Womanizer PRO40 is waterproof, with a plain design that is a welcome change. The PRO40 is not overtly feminine, thank god, and is in fact pretty damn plain. Somehow the PRO40 gained a feature (it’s now waterproof, like the Satisfyer) AND is priced much less. How is this possible? Well the motor is a little louder; they’ve gone with a cheaper motor that still performs well, but is less refined, I guess.  It may still be more expensive, but the PRO40 has the features that keep me coming back to Womanizer – the low settings and better navigation buttons. The PRO40 combines the best of the W100 (body, button placement) with the best of the W500 (extra power for those who need it, and up/down level navigation buttons), adds in waterproofing and takes away cost. I’m happy to have a slightly louder motor in exchange.

The lowest two settings on the Womanizers are subtle and arousing. They feel really good, and aren’t necessarily trying to yank an orgasm out of you. In fact the lower settings on the Womanizers are really great warm-up toys, and can build arousal in me in ways that the Fiera never could. Have I mentioned the buttons? Oh the buttons. You can easily toggle between lower and higher settings. I like to draw things out with the Womanizer (usually) because it feels so nice; so I don’t want to rush, I want to keep edging my orgasm. I can start out at 1 until I find some good porn; increase to 2 when I’m more aroused; tip it up to 3 to get the ball rolling; back down to 2 for a minute to keep things going. Up to 4 to pick up the pace; 3 then 2 then back up to 4 and maybe 5 if I need a boost and want to come. It’s the sex toy version of Monica’s ergoneous zones playlist.  I cannot do that with the Satisfyer Pro 2. With all Womanizer models I can quickly return to the lowest setting; perfect for just after orgasm. It’s just tolerably intense in those sensitive moments, but allows me to actually keep going and have multiple orgasms. I can’t do that with the Satisfyer because I’d have to turn it off completely to get back down to the gentle first setting (new model; old model has nothing “gentle” about it). These features are crucially important to me.

Even though the Womanizer Pro 40 is a little louder vs W100 or W500, it’s now my top recommendation over every brand and model.

Womanizer vs Satisfyer – Comparison Chart *

  Womanizer PRO40 Womanizer W100 Womanizer W500 Satisfyer Pro 2 (old) Satisfyer Pro 2 (new)
Power button brings you back to level 1 Y Y Y N N
Easy-to-hold Design  Y Y  — Y Y
Multiple color offerings Y Y Y N N
Gender-neutral colors/designs Y N N Y Y
Motor decibels 50-74 50-62 50-72 72-75 63-75
# of intensity levels 8 6 8 11 11
Plus & minus level navigation Y N Y N N
Multiple sized nozzle heads Y Y Y N N
Waterproof Y N N Y Y
Perceived Intensity, scale of 1-10 9 8 9 10 10
Price $99 $159 $219 $59 $59
Warranty 2 yrs ?* ?* N N
Use Time 240 mins 90 mins 240 mins ?* ?*
Charge Time 2 hours 4 hours 2 hours 2 hours 2 hours
Storage N Case Pouch Pouch Pouch

Womanizer W100

Womanizer W100It’s ugly, but it works – One thing that the Womanizer W100 has that the others lack is a really nice storage case. Sure, it’s baby-pink and has “Womanizer” emblazoned on it, but it’s really nice to keep the extra head, and charging accessories, all together.  The W100 is the quietest model because it lacks the more intense levels. I feel that when the Womanizer W100 is pressed against your vulva, it’s nearly silent. Even when you break contact, it’s not that loud – 62 decibels. The Womanizer W100 has only one button but the power button can be tapped during use to bring you back down to the first intensity level. And of course the W100 line is the most gaudy, with a big faux-rhinestone button to boot. Shevibe carries it in Pink Croc, Black Leopard and Red Roses; for a little more money Lovehoney carries it in Black “Tattoo” or Pink Leopard.

Womanizer W500

Womanizer W500One word: Awkward – For as much as I loved the Womanizer W100, I thought I’d love the W500 even more. Sure, it introduced the necessary plus and minus buttons to easily navigate the increased levels, but the power button was harder to press. The buttons are now located on the back side of the body, facing away from you, and are located in a place that is very awkward for me during use. The short, fat stature also makes it harder for me to hold.  The designs of the Womanizer W500 are a little more classy, but still very femme with the exception White Chrome design – but even that has a Swarovski crystal “element” as the power button.  The W500 is priced way, way too high at $219. It’s absolutely ridiculous and I can’t recommend this model with the other choices available. The W500 comes in the aforementioned White Chrome; Black Leopard, Red Roses, and Magenta Lace.

Satisfyer Pro 2 – The Old and The New

Satisfyer Pro 2Affordable? Nah, Cheap – Rather than rename the Satisfyer Pro 2, the company made two changes and kept the name and design the same. This means that with most retailers you won’t know which model you’re buying, because they’re priced the same, too. You’d only know to see it in person – the new version has “Satisfyer” in raised lettering along the handle (shown below). Satisfyer boasted that the new Pro 2 was “90% more quiet” than before. Where do these companies come up with this stuff? Using my amateur decibel meter the difference is only 9 points – the loudest rating on the lowest setting is 63dB on the new model vs 72dB on the old. It’s definitely noticeable, but not 90%. And the high levels? Identical when not pressed against the vulva – when pressed against the vulva, the new Pro 2 is a bit more quiet.  While Satisfyer does have a few more models and designs, most retailers don’t carry them right now.  If I test them, info on those will be updated here.  The Satisfyer Pro 2 comes in one color that is very gender-neutral, even if the packaging isn’t4.

satisfyerpro2-old-vs-new

*  A few things to note about this comparison chart:

  1. As new similar products are available to retailers, and I try them, I’ll add them to the chart. By similar I mean no vibrations, just this air pulsing whoosiewhatsit.
  2. Womanizer W100 and W500 previously had warranties, but things have changed and now I’m not sure. On Shevibe the “warranty” icon is not displayed for these two products. I’m waiting on confirmation.
  3. The decibels were tested with my phone and a sound meter. Due to the idling-engine type sound that the motors make on low, the sound meter jumped around a lot. The lower numbers then represent the loudest that the first settings will get. Also, I tested the sound levels without the nozzle being completely covered, like it would be in use. When the nozzle is completely covered the sound is dampened a lot.
  4. Charge and use time reports are varying from retailer info to manufacturer website / product manual info.  One reports the Satisfyer has 120 minutes of use, while their web-version user manual reports only 30 minutes. When I can get an accurate number, I’ll add it.
  5. I feel that the fat & short design of the Womanizer W500 is awkward to hold and more awkward to press buttons. Womanizer boasts it being more comfortable to hold. We’ll agree to disagree, I guess.

~   ~   ~   ~   ~   ~   ~   ~   ~   ~ 

While some folks are so turned off by the Womanizer name that that alone will make them buy the Satisfyer, if you didn’t know the names then you’d see that the Womanizer is the best. They pioneered this new type of sensation and while they’ve started off with designs that make most folks cringe and a name that you are loathe to utter, the Womanizer motor is superior. If Womanizer would lower the price on the Pro40 to $79, I feel they’d have the market cornered again. But for now my vote is with Womanizer Pro40 and Shevibe is naturally the retailer I’ll direct you to.

  1. At first the Womanizer W100 was priced at $189 at Shevibe, $199 many other places. In recent months Womanizer has dropped the price and now Shevibe sells it for $159 – this is the lowest price it should be sold for. Womanizer has a VERY stringent MAP agreement that any retailer must follow. If you see someone who isn’t, approach with caution
  2. White label is when a manufacturing plant makes a product, but they are not necessarily a brand – they offer to make things for your brand. You, the brand company, don’t really design anything, you just slap your brand name on the packaging and maybe pick a slightly different color scheme. This is why you can often see a dozen nearly-identical sex toys on the sub-par retailer market
  3. Side note: why the hell do these companies think bloggers are retailers?
  4. features a white femme person
 Posted by at 4:00 pm
  • FieryRed

    LOVE the chart!! Overall, excellent info as always. <3

  • Jac

    How loud would you say the Pro40 is compared to the We Vibe Tango?

  • They’re hard to compare because the sounds are different. When the Pro40 is sealed to your vulva it’s damn near silent. And when the Tango is on lower speeds I feel it’s very quiet and unobtrusive. But on the higher settings of the Pro40, when not sealed to your body, it could be a bit louder/more noticeable than the Tango.

  • Pawesl

    Thank You for this. Been looking everywhere for some type of comparison for these and some explanation as to why the newer model gained a feature but is $50 less.

  • Tzipora

    Thanks so, so much for your awesome comparison chart and all this info. I think I opened this review from your email newsletter then forgot to read it until I stumbled on it just now. Literally hadn’t even heard about the $99 Womanizer and now I’m SO glad I didn’t go buy the Womanizer Pro for Black Friday like I was planning. Why bother when there’s a lower priced one that is also waterproof?

    Seriously, awesome work here testing and comparing these all. I am curious though, have you tried the Pro40 in the bath by chance? Does it feel any different? I guess I’m remembering the RevelBody or whatever and how they had this underwater auction deal going on (for some people it seemed to be the only good part of that toy lol) but eh Womanizer has the suction thing anyhow so maybe there’s noticeable difference? I’m just curious. Definitely picking one up, maybe combined with a sale or something. Infinitely more affordable for sure.

  • Me and baths and sex toys don’t mix. I don’t have a big enough tub at home for this sort of activity, and the large tub I occasionally have access to is TOO large, or rather I’m too short, so I end up sliding down and chaos ensues. The Bubble Love review details that quite well =/

  • Tzipora

    Ahh. Okay. Makes sense. I’ve got issues with tubs to some extent being short as well and with my medical stuff so not a common occurrence for me anyhow. Miss it (and the faucet my parents used to have before they got sold a water saving one. A younger me took loooong baths two or three times a week. Young me was also a flexible, thin ballet dancer though too. ;)

    I don’t think I’ve seen anyone else review the Pro40 yet (admittedly I mostly read just a handful of bloggers i trust anyhow) but guess we shall see.

  • Tzipora

    My Womanizer Pro40 arrived today. OMG! My first orgasm was good but nothing impressive because I sort of forced it out and was grinding against and sort of moving the toy around to make it happen. Turns out even for a self proclaimed lazy girl the absolute laziness that Womanizer requires took some adjusting to. That and it didn’t make me come near as fast as most people, from reviews I’ve read so I kinda got bored but I went again and let it happen and oh my g-d. I have never had an orgasm like that before. It wouldn’t stop. It just kept happening. Even when I was consciously thinking “oh my g-d, it’s not stopping!” It still didn’t stop. Was it you or Piph who sorta described it as forcing orgasms out of you? Because that’s kind of what happened and eh as someone who has trouble keeping their head in the game, so to speak, I think I liked it. Only problem was I finally had to make it stop because my weak body and muscles (I mean I think from my health issues not the orgasm itself) just could not take anymore and I half thought I was going to faint or something. But oh my gosh do I feel good now. Hahaha. I’ve never felt so high or giggly for so long after unless I had a really good squirting orgasm. And this wasn’t that.

    So uh, I just needed to share somewhere. Haha. Hurt my wrist to use as well so I’m meh on it’s supposed accessibility (and curious if the shape of the Pro500 would’ve been better or worse for that?) but I made some adjustments and perhaps I’ll figure it out better still with more use. But holy cow, count me in as one more convert. Jeez. If that becomes a regular occurrence I’m calling this thing my new antidepressant. Woah.

  • HeadlessLegoMom

    Did you try it in the bath? I am considering doing so tonight because my comet arrived & my new memory foam bath pillow just got delivered as well. I have never taken a toy in the tub though, and I am afraid of breaking it.

  • HeadlessLegoMom

    I just wanted to thank you for this amazing comparison! I feel confident that the Womanizer Pro40 was the right decision for me, and I was able to also purchase Jopen’s discontinued Comet with the money I saved not buying the 500.

  • Nick

    The decibel scale is logarithmic, so to get an increase iof 3dB, you need to double the sound intensity. So, numerically, 9dB doesn’t seem lik a whole lot, it’s actually a huge difference.

  • Thank you! The science is very appreciated :)

  • Alex

    There’s now the Satisfyer Pro Penguin – what’s the difference between that and the Satisfyer Pro 2? I can’t get anywhere with my googling, unfortunately :(

  • I’m hoping to try these out, and when I do, this post will get updated.

    From what I’ve read the Penguin is slightly less intense than the Pro2, the nozzle opening is slightly larger but has a thinner more defined edge to it that may end up proving uncomfortable for some folks. Otherwise it’s down to shape and size of the body. The controls are the same – forcing you to cycle through all 11 settings and then back down through all 11 – it’s a pain in the ass if you decide it’s too intense and you want to just back down by 1 level.